Template:Mayo All Stars record

Mayo has 54 All Stars, as of 2021. 33 different players have won, as of 2021. Lee Keegan won five All Stars, while Colm Boyle won four.

denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year that season.

1971: Johnny Carey
1979: Joe McGrath
1985: Dermot Flanagan, Willie Joe Padden, Kevin McStay
1989: Gabriel Irwin, Jimmy Browne, Dermot Flanagan^2nd, Willie Joe Padden^2nd, Noel Durkin
1992: T. J. Kilgallon
1993: Kevin O'Neill
1996: Kenneth Mortimer, Pat Holmes, James Nallen, Liam McHale, James Horan
1997: Kenneth Mortimer^2nd, Pat Fallon
1999: James Horan^2nd
2004: James Nallen^2nd, Ciarán McDonald
2006: Alan Dillon, Conor Mortimer
2011: Andy Moran
2012: Ger Cafferkey, Keith Higgins, Lee Keegan, Alan Dillon^2nd
2013: Keith Higgins^2nd, Lee Keegan^2nd, Colm Boyle, Aidan O'Shea
2014: Keith Higgins^3rd, Colm Boyle^2nd, Cillian O'Connor
2015: Lee Keegan^3rd, Aidan O'Shea^2nd
2016: David Clarke, Brendan Harrison, Lee Keegan ^4th, Colm Boyle^3rd
2017: David Clarke^2nd, Chris Barrett, Keith Higgins^3rd Colm Boyle^4th, Aidan O'Shea^3rd, Andy Moran ^2nd
2019: Paddy Durcan
2020: Oisín Mullin, Cillian O'Connor^2nd
2021: Lee Keegan^5th, Matthew Ruane, Ryan O'Donoghue